Everything you say here, Dolores, is true to a degree, but I disagree with your take on it. Getting to #1 by getting a group of folks to have a listen is difficult and unlikely in most cases. Also, the song has to be either downloaded or streamed for at least a minute to count in the ratings, and I think that's important because I know I have listened to many songs for 30 seconds and turned it off because I didn't like it. It takes people returning to listen again and referring friends to the song, etc. In other words, the song has to have something to offer to make it popular, just like in retail publishing, so it *does* say something about the quality of the song in most cases.
And as for vanity publishing, nobody is paying money to be on Soundclick. And how many of us have spent money to produce a CD of our songs simply to hand out as demos? Is that 'vanity publishing' or self -promotion?
